Breaking News

Lavrov Sounds False Alarm Over ‘Staged’ Syria Strikes


U.S. -- Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov speaks during the United Nations Security Council briefing on counterproliferation on the second day of the UN General Assembly September, at the United Nations in New York, 26, 2018
Sergey Lavrov

Sergey Lavrov

Russian Foreign Minister

"There's an alarming situation regarding the issue of chemical disarmament. First of all, this is in connection with the actions of a number of Western states accusing the Syrian authorities with more and more unsubstantiated allegations of using banned chemical agents. We warn [the West] against new strikes on the territory of the Syrian Arab Republic under another staged pretext.”

False
“Unsubstantiated’ claims of chemical weapons use in Syria are anything but.

Speaking at a UN Security Council meeting on Wednesday, September 27, Russian Foreign Minister Lavrov accused the West of leveling “unsubstantiated allegations” against Syrian authorities for using banned chemical weapons, further warning against “new strikes on the territory of the Syrian Arab Republic under another staged pretext."

In August, Lavrov said that Russia had called for inspections by the Organization of the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW) to investigate alleged chemical weapons attacks, claiming its “Western colleagues” had moved to block those efforts.

He similarly said "the chemical weapons provocation which is being prepared" is aimed at keeping Al-Nusra in Syria.

But like allegations that it is the West which is standing in the way of Syrian inspections, Lavrov’s charge of “staged pretexts” being used to justify Western airstrikes is false.

After the Ghouta chemical weapons attack in August 2013, which saw up to 1,729 killed in a sarin gas attack on the outskirts of Damascus, Lavrov called intelligence findings that the Syrian state was responsible “unconvincing.”

Syria -- Children walk along a damaged street filled with debris in the Damascus suburb of Zamalka, October 3, 2013
Syria -- Children walk along a damaged street filled with debris in the Damascus suburb of Zamalka, October 3, 2013

Nonetheless, Russia, in concert with the United States, hammered out a framework under which Syria would give up its chemical weapon stockpiles. In line with that framework, Damascus acceded to the Chemical Weapons Convention (CWC) and became a member of the OPCW. United Nations Security Council Resolution 2118 gave Syria until the middle of 2014 to destroy its chemical weapons arsenal.

On June 23, 2014, OPCW head Ahmet Üzümcü announced the last of Syria’s chemical weapons had been shipped out of the country for destruction.

Syria -- A TV grab shows an inspector from the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW) at work at an undisclosed location in Syria, October 8, 2013
Syria -- A TV grab shows an inspector from the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW) at work at an undisclosed location in Syria, October 8, 2013

But on September 10, 2014 the OPCW found "compelling confirmation" that chlorine gas had been used "systematically and repeatedly” as a weapon in Syria.

While chlorine in and of itself is not within the purview of the disarmament agreement, its use as a weapon of war does violate the CWC.

A later report released in August 2016 by the OPCW-UN Joint Investigative Mechanism (JIM), which was tasked with determining who had carried out chemical weapons attacks in Syria, found that the Assad regime had been responsible for incidents on April 2014 in Talmenes and March 2015 in Sarmin. The following month, the JIM issued another report pointing the finger at Damascus for a third chlorine gas attack on March 16, 2015 in Idlib province.

Syria -- A young man sits on a bed at a clinic in the village of Sarmin, southeast of Idlib, March 17, 2015
Syria -- A young man sits on a bed at a clinic in the village of Sarmin, southeast of Idlib, March 17, 2015

On April 4, 2017, a sarin gas attack killed dozens in northern Idlib province. But on April 12, Russia vetoed a UN Security Council Resolution condemning that attack.

On October 24, two days before the OPCW-UN Joint Investigative Mechanism (JIM) found the Assad regime guilty of using sarin nerve agent in the April 4 Idlib attack, Russia vetoed a resolution to extend the mechanism’s mandate, which expired on November 17. A further resolution to extend the JIM’s mandate introduced by Japan that November was also vetoed by Russia.

Then, following two smaller chemical weapons attacks in March 2018, a suspected chemical attack in the Damascus suburb of Douma on April 7 killed at least 49 people and wounded up to 650.

Syria - empty rocket reportedly fired by regime forces on the rebel-held besieged town of Douma
Syria - empty rocket reportedly fired by regime forces on the rebel-held besieged town of Douma

On April 10, Russia vetoed a US resolution to establish a UN Independent Mechanism of Investigation with a one-year mandate to investigate responsible parties in Syrian chemical weapons attacks. Russia then proposed an investigative body that would have given the UN Security Council the final say on accountability, granting Moscow veto power over any findings.

Four days later, the United States, France and Britain conducted airstrikes on sites allegedly connected to Syria’s chemical weapons program.

On September 12, the UN Commission of Inquiry on Syria, which is investigating war crimes there, documented three further uses of banned chlorine weapons by Syrian government forces that constituted war crimes, according to Reuters.

That brought the number of incidents documented by that commission since 2013 to 39. Of those 39 attacks, 33 were attributed to the Assad regime, while perpetrators in the other six had not been sufficiently identified.

SYRIA – A photo released early on April 14, 2018 on the website of the official Syrian Arab News Agency shows an explosion on the outskirts of Damascus after Western strikes reportedly hit Syrian military bases and chemical research centres in and around
SYRIA – A photo released early on April 14, 2018 on the website of the official Syrian Arab News Agency shows an explosion on the outskirts of Damascus after Western strikes reportedly hit Syrian military bases and chemical research centres in and around

Earlier, on the first anniversary of the April4, 2017 Idlib incident, a Human Rights Watch report, which collated data from seven sources, found that the majority of 85 confirmed chemical weapon attacks in Syria by that time had been carried out by the Syrian government.

Based on the preponderance of evidence pointing to the Syrian government’s use of chemical weapons, Lavrov’s claims of “unsubstantiated allegations” or the potential of “another staged pretext” to initiate military action there are false.

XS
SM
MD
LG